In April 2018, Butterfly Table Tennis has announced new coming “Butterfly Tenergy 05 Hard Version” in the list of authorized racket covering (LARC by ITTF). Because Tenergy 05 is one of the best backhand rubber on the market right now. So why Butterfly introduces this NEW Tenergy 05 Harder version? What are the advantages of this version versus the normal Tenergy 05 version? Here is the review.
Tenergy 05 Hard vs Tenergy 05 Normal vs Tenergy 05 FX
So until now, there are 3 types of Tenergy 05 rubbers (with different sponge hardness)
- Tenergy 05 Hard (firmer sponge – sponge hardness 43)
- Tenergy 05 (normal version – sponge hardness 36)
- and Tenergy 05 FX (softer version – sponge hardness 32)
Both of these 3 types (Ten05 Hard, Ten 05 and Ten05 FX) have the same topsheet.
TENERGY 05 HARD spec
| Product name | Tenergy 05 Hard |
|---|---|
| Read reviews | Reviews 1 |
| Check Price | Price 1/ Price 2 |
| Release date | November 1, 2018 (Available on Amazon/ Megaspin/ Butterfly Store) |
| type | High tension pimple in rubber |
| technology | High tension, spring sponge |
| speed | 13 |
| spin | 11.5 |
Here is the performance rating of Tenergy 05 Hard (provided by Butterfly Catalogue 2019). These ratings are based on the Butterfly R&D Team. By doing several tests, they have provided this rubber chart.
| Sponge hardness | 43 |
|---|---|
| Sheet color | Red (006), black (278) |
| Sponge Thickness | 2.1 mm |
| Fabrication country | Japan |
Butterfly Tenergy 05 Hard | Unboxing and First Impressions
Dan of TableTennisDaily has made a nice unboxing and review of the Tenergy 05 Hard.
TENERGY 05 Normal spec
Here is the performance test of the Butterfly Tenerg 05 (Normal version).
TENERGY 05 FX spec
Compared to Tenergy 05, Tenergy 05 FX offers the more “all-round” ability. The easy of blocking and short game has been improved.
Comparison between Ten05 Hard, Ten05, and Ten05 fx
Here is the comparison chart of these 3 types of Tenergy 05.
As expected, the Tenergy 05 Hard performs very well at (strength and advantages):
- Ease of counter looping (yes! Harder sponge helps a lot)
- Ease of Short Game (due to harder sponge, less bouncy at the soft touch)
- Ease of Fast Loop (like counter looping, the player feels safer to close more the racket’s angle)
However, there is some weakness of the Tenergy 05 Hard:
- Difficult to smash (Yes! You need to apply more direct force to get the same speed as using Tenergy 05 normal version)
- Harder to block (The same! You need to be more active to block! Otherwise, the ball will drop to the net often)
- Less Spin on service (For the softer touch, Ten05 Hard produces less spin. But it increases the speed at counter loop)
Conclusion:
So if your playing style relies on the service, and spin variation, you should choose the Tenergy 05 Normal version. But if you win the points more with power and speed (counter-attack style), you should choose Tenergy 05 Hard.
Tenergy Rubber Mass and Density Comparison
| Brand | Model | Sponge Thickness (mm) | Mass (g) | Sponge density (g/cm2) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Butterfly | Tenergy 05 HARD | 2.1 | 76 | 0.255 |
| Butterfly | Tenergy 05 | 2.1 | 70 | 0.235 |
| Butterfly | Tenergy 05 FX | 2.1 | 67 | 0.225 |
| Butterfly | Tenergy 80 | 2.1 | 67.5 | 0.227 |
| Butterfly | Tenergy 80 FX | 2.1 | 64.5 | 0.217 |
| Butterfly | Tenergy 64 | 2.1 | 65 | 0.218 |
| Butterfly | Tenergy 64 FX | 2.1 | 62 | 0.208 |
| Butterfly | Tenergy 25 | 2.1 | 72 | 0.242 |
| Butterfly | Tenergy 25 FX | 2.1 | 69 | 0.232 |
So Butterfly wants to introduce the new Tenery 05 rubber with the harder sponge! And the topsheet is the same! But why?
Is Tenergy 05 Hard sponge too firm?
The SpinArt sponge has 48 hardness degree, while the normal version of Tenergy 05 has 36 hardness degree. So Tenergoy 05 Hard with 43 hardness is something between SpinArt and Tenergy 05. So for me, 43 hardness scale is the right scale for the new poly ball. It’s not too hard!
As I’ve explained before, that before this official version of Tenergy 05 Hard, many professional players have used the Hard Version of Tenergy 05!
Pro players already used “Tenergy 05 Pro version” before 2015
The pro version is only available for the sponsored players, which is not available on the market. This version is much harder than the commercial version, confirmed by Timo Boll.
Professional players using Tenergy 05 Hard
Many top players who are sponsored by Butterfly like Timo Boll, Marcos Freitas, Harimoto Tomokazu, Lee Seung Soo, Wong Chun Ting, Chuang Chi Yuan, Tiago Apolónia, etc, already have the “Tenergy 05 Hard” in their hand before us 🙂
For example, Marcos Freitas has posted his “professional version” of Tenergy 05.
Or Tomokazu Harimoto also has his custom Tenergy 05 version. Miu Hirano also used the Tenergy rubbers (pro version).
Why firmer sponge Tenergy 05?
As I have explained previously, with the new Poly ball used in table tennis, this shift is necessary.
As many table tennis brands like (Donic, Stiga, Andro) have introduced their “P-series rubbers” for the new poly ball.
And now, Butterfly can’t go outside of this trend! They want to join the market with their leadership products Tenergy 05!
And here you are, “Tenergy 05 Hard version”!
The new ball which is harder, heavier, thicker has made the “new trends in table tennis”. This trend affects not only the table tennis coach, athlete to change their techniques, but also the table tennis equipment.
Notes: Search “new trends pingsunday” to understand more what needs to change in term of your table tennis techniques.
Tenergy 05 is not hard enough
This is the smart move of Butterfly to offer the player the harder version of Ten05. Because the Tenergy 05 normal version is not hard enough for this modern game.
Nowadays, with the 40+ ball, every player like to hit very hard! They want to hammer every shot at any distance! This is the new style in table tennis!
Not only the pro players, but the competitive players want to use the hard version! It’s a confirmed trend!
Who should use Tenergy 05 Hard?
With the harder sponge, the Tenergy 05 Hard is, no doubt, for intermediate players and advanced players.
The player who has the high swing speed can opt to this hard version. However, harder sponge means heavier, and harder to control at the short distance!
If you find that it’s too difficult for you to handle this, you can try the normal Tenergy 05 version or even the Tenergy 05 FX.
Choose the hardness scale that fit your style and your level!
How to protect the topsheet of Tenergy 05 Hard
This rubber is made of a very delicate topsheet. During several hours of using, it is easily vulnerable to the broken rubber edge, loss of grippy topsheet surface. To protect the rubber, after use, I recommend you to guard the rubber in a dry situation. And always using the film for protection.
The sticky film can help to protect the topsheet surface of the butterfly rubbers (check price). It’s not expensive but is necessary. Like your blade, the rubber doesn’t like the humidity. Butterfly also recommend players to glue the rubber correctly. They explained, “to maintains the incredible ‘Spring Sponge’ feel, please use Free Chack II when you glue perfectly Tenergy rubbers to a blade.”.
You should also combine the Tenergy 05 Hard rubbers on the right blade. Check here for the top 10 blades that professional players use.
References:
- Tenergy 05 Hard: Reviewed by Current US National Team Coach, Stefan Feth, Butterfly 2018
- Let us introduce you to the next “Game Changer” – Tenergy 05 Hard, Butterfly 2018
Related Posts
Hi Coach,
I already sent you the wrap footnotes up.
Do hope you can fix it to better content.
Regards,
Uli Hasuri
Dear Hasuri,
I’ve replied to you with my email. Have you received it? Yes, I got your files, and I have proposed some advice and sent it back to you.
Regards,
ERT
Different manufactures use different durometer systems to measure/rate the sponge hardness of their rubber products (e.g., Shore A, Shore O, Asker C, Asker E, etc.). DHS sponge hardness typically ranges from 35 to 42, presumably based on the Shore A scale. You’ve reported that Butterfly rates its hard, normal and soft Tenergy 05 sponge as 43, 36 and 32 hardness, respectively (possibly using the Asker E scale). Do you know DHS sponge hardness that’s equivalent to the Butterfly 43 hardness of Tenergy 05 hard? (I’ve been assuming it’s roughly 37-39 to avoid issues such as boosting, etc.). Thanks in advance for considering this query. m2
Yes, you are right. M2Reno, I will explain the different scale in table tennis hardness. Due to different type of Shore. Regards
Hello coach,
What tenergy rubber suits my playing style (counter-driver) like mima ito. And can you suggest blades for me too.
Hope to hear from you coach.
Much love,
Angelo Galamgam
Philippines
Mima Ito used short-pips on her backhand. Do you want to use Ten05 for bh or fh?
since it is harder,should i use a flexible blade too to get the kick effect?
yes, Harimoto has also confirmed that he prefers a flexible blade which can increase spin a bit. So I think yes, you can try a flexible blade with Tenergy 05 hard.
i have tried 05 harder its only for player who want to finish the ball with more powerflul that ruuber less spin and speed good for cunter spin drive but not that for players who love to spin the ball many attacking like china rubber or 05 rubber
Tenergy 05 hard is better than the esn rubber. Good move of Butterfly
Just tried 05 hard ,not for me !less spin hard to control and you need a very soft blade.So not a carbon or ZLC!
Coach
very helpful thanks for your thoughts
Question would you recommend Tenergy hard (43) for black forehand and Tenergy Med (36) red for backhand. In another post you mention that the difference should only be +2. I am a beginner/intermediate player looking to improve quickly. Will I notice such a big difference between 43 and 36 to make it feel strange? Also I am considering a flexible all-wood bat such as the Timo Ball allrounder. Thanks for your thoughts here….
Hello. You are right. In general, you can use both Ternergy Normal for both Forehand and Backhand. Tenergy Hard is used to counter attack with the new ball.
So if you style relies on counter attack, use Ten Hard. If you want to loop, topspin on FH, use Ten Normal.
Per the a Shore C to Shore A conversion chart (http://mytabletennis.net/forum/sponge-hardness_topic43435.html) it appears that Tenergy05 Hard 43 Shore C is “only” 35 in Shore A.
Given that I already am using a chinese rubber on my backhand (Dawei Super Power 2008) 2.0mm & 40deg, going to the Tenergy would be kind of like a step backward for me?
I’m using Xiom Hibi O Tour JPen hino kinoki 10mm and I am contemplating changing the rubber to 2.1mm Butterfly Tenergy 05 Hard.
Will the combined thickness of the blade, sponge & rubber be a problem?